Social Innovation Assessment? Reflections on the impacts of social innovation on society - Outcomes of a systematic literature review

¿Evaluación de la innovación social? Reflexiones sobre los impactos de la innovación social en la sociedad - Resultados de una revisión sistemática de la literatura

  • Georg Mildenberger CSI - Centre for Social Investment, Heidelberg University
  • Gudrun Schimpf CSI - Centre for Social Investment, Heidelberg University
  • Jürgen Streicher Joanneum Research, Institute for Economic and Innovation Research
Keywords: social innovation, structured literature review, impact, assessment, dark side, reflections, consequences, measurement.

Abstract

Today we face many societal problems, such as climate degradation, energy shortages, increasing inequality, and demographic change. Solutions for these problems require far-reaching changes and new and untried approaches. Social Innovation (SI) could be a significant factor in tackling the challenges to come. The ‘reflection on the long-term effects of social innovations’ is a relatively new topic but is attracting growing interest. While technology assessments are regularly used to study the consequences of technical innovations, similar assessments for social innovations are rare. This paper explores and analyses the current state of theoretical, conceptual work on the assessment for SI and their consequences, related concepts, and relevant activities. Perspectives and options for further developments in this field are derived. The method used is a structured literature review. The results show that scientific research concerning the assessment of the consequences of social innovations seems to be still in its infancy. The boundaries between established topics (such as sustainability, user orientation, including social entrepreneurship) and newer concepts are fluid. However, alongside the different approaches and views, a certain convergence of perspectives with regard to the consequences and effects of (social) innovations can be observed. Similar questions and issues are dealt with using similar approaches and methods, and are sometimes confronted with similar obstacles.

 

Resumen

Hoy enfrentamos problemas sociales como la degradación ambiental, carencias energéticas, creciente desigualdad y cambio demográfico. Las soluciones para estos problemas requieren cambios profundos y enfoques nuevos. La Innovación Social (IS) podría ser un factor significativo para abordar los desafíos venideros. La “reflexión sobre los efectos a largo plazo de la innovación social" es un tema relativamente nuevo, pero suscita un interés creciente. Si bien las evaluaciones tecnológicas se utilizan regularmente para estudiar las consecuencias de las innovaciones técnicas, otro tipo de evaluaciones son raramente utilizadas. Este artículo explora y analiza el estado actual del trabajo teórico y conceptual sobre la evaluación de la IS y sus consecuencias, conceptos relacionados y actividades relevantes. También se obtienen perspectivas y opciones para futuros desarrollos en este campo. El método utilizado es la revisión de la literatura estructurada. Los resultados muestran que la investigación científica sobre la evaluación de las consecuencias de las innovaciones sociales parece estar todavía en sus inicios. Los límites entre los temas establecidos (la sostenibilidad, orientación al usuario, emprendimiento social) y los conceptos más nuevos son fluidos. Sin embargo, junto a los diferentes enfoques y visiones, se puede observar una cierta convergencia de perspectivas en cuanto a las consecuencias y efectos de las innovaciones (sociales). Las cuestiones y problemas similares se abordan utilizando enfoques y métodos similares y, a veces, se enfrentan a obstáculos similares.

Palabras clave: innovación social; revisión de literatura estructurada; impacto; evaluación; lado oscuro; reflexiones; consecuencias; medición.

 

DOI: https://doi.org/10.31637/epsir.20-2.1

References

Albuquerque, C. P., & Rocha, S. (2019). Third Sector and Social Innovation in Local Communities in Portugal: Dilemmas Concerning Framing and Measurement of Social Impact. In New Paths of Entrepreneurship Development (pp. 257-281). Springer, Cham. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-96032-6_13

Anania, L., & Passani, A. (2014). A Hitchhiker’s guide to digital social innovation [paper] 20th ITS Biennial Conference, Rio de Janeiro.

Anheier, H.K., Krlev, G., Preuss, S., Mildenberger, G., Bekkers, R.H.F.P., Mensink, W., Bauer, A., Knapp, M., Wistow, G., Hernandez, A., & Adelaja, B. (2014). Social Innovation as Impact of the Third Sector. Deliverable of the project: “Impact of the Third Sector as Social Innovation” (ITSSOIN), European Commission - 7th Framework Programme. Brussels.

Avelino, F., Wittmayer, J. M., Pel, B., Weaver, P., Dumitru, A., Haxeltine, A., Kemp, R., Jørgensen, M. S., Bauler, T., Ruijsink, S., & O'Riordan, T. (2019). Transformative social innovation and (dis) empowerment. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 145, 195-206.

BEPA (2010). Empowering people, driving change: Social Innovation in the European Union. France.

Brandsen, T., Evers, A., Cattacin, S., & Zimmer, A. (2016). The Good, the Bad and the Ugly in Social Innovation. In T. Brandsen, S. Cattacin, A. Evers, & A. Zimmer (Eds.), Nonprofit and Civil Society Studies. Social Innovations in the Urban Context (pp. 303–310). Cham: Springer. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-21551-8_9

Caulier-Grice, J., Davies, A., Patrick, R., & Norman, W. (2012). Defining social innovation. A deliverable of the project. The Theoretical, Empirical and Policy Foundations for Building Social Innovation in Europe (TEPSIE), European Commission-7th Framework Programme. Brussels: European Commission, DG Research.

Dhondt, S., Ven, H., Cressey, P., Kaderabkova, A., Luna, Á., Moghadam Saman, S., Casto, J., Žiauberytė-Jakštienė, R., Van der Torre, W., & Terstriep, J. (2016). Evaluation Toolbox - Ex-Ante Impact Assessment & Value Network Analysis for SI: Simpact Project Report. Gelsenkirchen. Available at: http://www.simpact-project.eu/publications/reports/simpact_d7.2.pdf

Fougère, M., & Meriläinen, E. (2019). Exposing three dark sides of social innovation through critical perspectives on resilience. Industry and Innovation, 1-18. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13662716.2019.1709420

Fougere, M., Segercrantz, B., & Seeck, H. (2017). A critical reading of the European Union’s social innovation policy discourse: (Re)legitimizing neoliberalism. Organization, 24(6), 819–843. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1350508416685171

Fuchs, G. (2001). Wirtschaft und Technikfolgenabschätzung-Aus der Arbeit der Akademie für Technikfolgenabschätzung in Baden-Württemberg. TATuP-Zeitschrift für Technikfolgenabschätzung in Theorie und Praxis, 10(2), 45-50.

Haxeltine, A., Pel, B., Wittmayer, J., Dumitru, A., Kemp, R., & Avelino, F. (2017). Building a middle-range theory of Transformative Social Innovation: Theoretical pitfalls and methodological responses. European Public & Social Innovation Review, 2(1), 59–77. DOI: https://doi.org/10.31637/epsir.17-1.5

Jenson, J., & Harrisson, D. (2013). Social innovation research in the European Union. Approaches, findings and future directions. Policy review, 978-92. Available at: 10.2777/12639

Kangas, O., Jauhiainen, S., Simanainen, M., & Ylikännö, M. (2019). The basic income experiment 2017–2018 in Finland: Preliminary results.

Kleverbeck, M., Krlev, G., Mildenberger, G., Strambach, S., Thurmann, J.-F., Terstriep, J., & Wloka, L. (2019). Indicators for measuring social innovation. In J. Howaldt, C. Kaletka, A. Schröder, & M. Zirngiebl (Eds.), Atlas of Social Innovation: Vol. 2. Atlas of Social Innovation. A World of New Practices (pp. 98–101). Munich: Oekom verlag.

Kleverbeck, M., Mildenberger, G., Schröer, A., & Terstriep, J. (2019). Regional social innovation networks. In S. M. Weber, I. Truschkat, C. Schröder, L. Peters, & A. Herz (Eds.), Organisation und Pädagogik: Vol. 26. Organisation und Netzwerke. Beiträge der Kommission Organisationspädagogik (pp. 355–374). Wiesbaden: Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-658-20372-6_33

Lösch, A., Böhle, K., Coenen, C., Dobroc, P., Ferrari, A., Heil, R., Hommrich, D., Sand, M., Grunwald, A., Dickel, S., Schulz-Schaeffer, I., & Wentland, A. (2016). Technikfolgenabschätzung von soziotechnischen Zukünften.

Moody, M., Littlepage, L., & Paydar, N. (2015). Measuring Social Return on Investment: Lessons from Organizational Implementation of SROI in the Netherlands and the United States. Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 26(1), 19–37. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/nml.21145

Moulaert, F., Mehmood, A., MacCallum, D., & Leubolt, B. (2017). Social innovation as a trigger for transformations-the role of research. Publications Office of the European Union. Brussels. DOI: 10.2777/68949

Nicholls, A., & Ziegler, R. (Eds.). (2019). Creating economic space for social innovation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Orazbayeva, B., & Dyrman, M. (2017). Tomorrow’s Land: Strategic Foresight Report 2017 - Intellectual Output 1.

Schimpf, G.-C., Mildenberger, G., Giesecke, S., & Havas, A. (2019). Trajectories of Social Innovation: Housing for All? In A. Nicholls & R. Ziegler (Eds.), Creating economic space for social innovation (pp. 109–148). Oxford: Oxford University Press. DOI: 10.1093/oso/9780198830511.003.0005

Segnestam Larsson, O., & Brandsen, T. (2016). The Implicit Normative Assumptions of Social Innovation Research: Embracing the Dark Side. In T. Brandsen, S. Cattacin, A. Evers, & A. Zimmer (Eds.), Nonprofit and Civil Society Studies. Social Innovations in the Urban Context (pp. 293–302). Cham: Springer. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-21551-8

Steen, T., Brandsen, T., & Verschuere, B. (2018). The Dark Side of Co-Creation and Co-Production: Seven Evils. In T. Brandsen, B. Verschuere, & T. Steen (Eds.), Routledge Critical Studies in Public Management Ser. Co-Production and Co-Creation. Engaging Citizens in Public Services (pp. 284–294). Milton: Routledge. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315204956

Swyngedouw, E. (2009). Civil Society, Governmentality and the Contradictions of Governance-beyond-the-State: The Janus-face of Social Innovation. In D. MacCallum, F. Moulaert, J. Hillier, & S. Vicari Haddock (Eds.), Social Innovation and Territorial Development (pp. 63–78). Farnham, Burlington, VT: Ashgate.

Westley, F., McGowan, K., & Tjörnbo, O. (Eds.). (2017). The Evolution of Social Innovation: Building Resilience Through Transitions. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Witkamp, M. J., Raven, R. P., & Royakkers, L. M. (2006). Strategic Niche Management of Social Innovation: the case of Social Entrepreneurship in the Netherlands. Working Paper.

Wruk, D., Oberg, A., & Friedrich-Schieback, M. (2019). Quantifying the sharing economy: An approach for measuring the ecological, social, and economic effects. Gaia-Ecological Perspectives for Science and Society, 28(1), 184–189. DOI: https://doi.org/10.14512/gaia.28.S1.3

Published
2020-12-30
How to Cite
Mildenberger, G., Schimpf, G., & Streicher, J. (2020). Social Innovation Assessment? Reflections on the impacts of social innovation on society - Outcomes of a systematic literature review. European Public & Social Innovation Review, 5(2), 1-13. Retrieved from https://pub.sinnergiak.org/esir/article/view/138
Section
Research articles